FIXED SCOPE SECURITY GAP ASSESSMENT

Cyber Security Assessment: Know Exactly Where You Stand.

A security gap assessment measures your cyber security today against a recognised framework, shows the gaps that matter most and gives you a prioritised plan to close them. Cautio’s assessment is independent, evidence-based and written in plain English for owners and boards, not just IT.

THE SHORT ANSWER

A gap assessment tells you where you are, where you need to be and what to fix first.

  • Current state: how mature each area of your security is today, scored against a recognised framework and backed by evidence.
  • Target state: the level your business actually needs, set from your risks, obligations, customers and budget, not the maximum possible.
  • The gaps, ranked: every shortfall rated by business risk, so the first dollar goes to the biggest problem.
  • A plan: quick wins for the next 90 days and a 12-month roadmap you can hand to your IT team, managed service provider or board.

CHOOSE YOUR YARDSTICK

Which framework should you be assessed against?

Pick the situation closest to yours. If none fits, we recommend one on the scoping call.

Your situation

We would assess you against

NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0

A broad, plain-English framework with six functions: Govern, Identify, Protect, Detect, Respond and Recover. It covers your whole security program, not just technical controls, so it is our default when there is no specific requirement.

We would assess you against

Essential Eight and ASD Essentials

We rate your Essential Eight maturity and map the results to ASD Essentials, the framework ASD published in October 2026 to replace it. See our Essential Eight page for what changed.

We would assess you against

ISO/IEC 27001:2022

We check your management system and Annex A controls against what a certification auditor expects, so you know the size of the job before you commit to an audit date.

We would assess you against

Information Security Manual (ISM)

ASD’s ISM is the control set Commonwealth agencies use. We focus on the controls your contracts actually require, rather than all of them.

We would assess you against

Your client’s requirements

We assess you against the questionnaire or schedule you have been given, show where you fall short and help you answer honestly.

Handling personal information? Whatever the framework, we also check the basics the Privacy Act expects, such as keeping personal information secure and being ready to respond to a notifiable data breach.

SCOPE

What does a security gap assessment cover?

We look at people, process and technology, because most breaches exploit a gap between them. A typical assessment covers these twelve areas, adjusted to your business.

  1. Governance and roles

    Who owns security, and how decisions reach the board

  2. Risk management

    Whether risks are known, recorded and acted on

  3. Policies

    Documented, approved and actually followed

  4. Assets and data

    What you have, where sensitive data lives

  5. Identity and access

    MFA, admin accounts, joiners and leavers

  6. Devices and email

    Hardening, protection and safe configuration

  7. Patching and vulnerabilities

    How fast known weaknesses get fixed

  8. Backups and recovery

    Tested, protected and fast enough

  9. Logging and detection

    Whether you would notice an attack

  10. Incident response

    A plan, a team and practice

  11. Suppliers and cloud

    The providers you depend on

  12. People and awareness

    Training, culture and phishing resilience

THE DELIVERABLE

What does the assessment report look like?

Short at the front for decision-makers, detailed at the back for whoever does the work. Here is the kind of scorecard you get.

Maturity scorecard

Example only

  • Govern2 → 3
  • Identify1 → 3
  • Protect3 → 4
  • Detect1 → 3
  • Respond2 → 3
  • Recover2 → 4
Illustration using the six NIST CSF 2.0 functions and a 0 to 5 maturity scale. Not a real client. Your report uses the framework you choose.

What you receive

  • One-page executive summary in plain English
  • Maturity scorecard: current and target level for each area
  • Gap register with each finding rated by business risk, with evidence
  • Quick wins for the next 90 days
  • 12-month roadmap with effort, cost drivers and suggested owners
  • A walkthrough session with your team, and with your board if you like

KNOW WHAT YOU ARE BUYING

Gap assessment vs audit vs penetration test

These answer different questions. Most businesses should start with a gap assessment, because it tells you whether the others are worth doing yet.

QuestionGap assessmentCertification auditPenetration testSupplier risk assessment
AnswersWhere are we, and what should we fix first?Do we meet the standard, pass or fail?Can an attacker break in through this system?Is it safe to rely on this supplier?
CoversYour whole program: people, process, technologyThe standard’s requirementsSpecific systems, technicallyOne supplier, product or project
ResultScorecard, ranked gaps and a roadmapCertificate or non-conformitiesTechnical vulnerabilities foundGo, go with conditions, or stop
Best timeFirst, before you spendWhen you are ready to certifyOnce basics are in placeBefore you sign or connect
Cautio does itYesWe prepare you; an accredited body certifiesNo; we help you scope oneYes, free check available

HOW IT WORKS

How does a Cautio gap assessment run?

  1. Free scoping call

    We agree the framework, which parts of the business are in scope and what is driving the work. You get a fixed quote and timeline.

  2. Documents and settings

    You share what already exists: policies, diagrams, reports and screenshots of key settings. We send a short list, so nobody hunts for things we do not need.

  3. Interviews and evidence review

    Focused conversations with the people who run your business and IT, remotely or on site, and a check of the evidence behind every answer.

  4. Report and walkthrough

    You receive the report and we walk you through it, agree the priorities and answer questions from your team or board.

NEXT STEPS

What happens after the assessment?

The roadmap is yours to use however you like. Many clients hand it to their IT team or managed service provider. If you want help, we can stay involved.

Do it yourselves

Use the roadmap

Everything is written so your team or provider can act on it without us. Book a re-assessment later to measure progress.

Ongoing

Keep someone in charge

A virtual CISO who owns the roadmap, reports to your board and keeps the program moving.

QUESTIONS

Frequently asked questions

What is a cyber security gap assessment?

A gap assessment measures your current security against a recognised framework, sets the target level your business needs, and lists the gaps between the two ranked by risk, with a roadmap to close them. It covers people, process and technology, not just IT settings.

How is a gap assessment different from a penetration test?

A penetration test checks whether an attacker can break into specific systems. A gap assessment looks at your whole security program and tells you what to fix first. Most businesses should do a gap assessment first, because it shows whether a penetration test is worth doing yet. Cautio does not perform penetration tests.

Is a gap assessment the same as an ISO 27001 audit?

No. A certification audit is a pass or fail check by an accredited body. A gap assessment tells you how far you are from meeting ISO 27001 and what to do about it, so you go into the audit prepared.

Which framework will you assess us against?

Usually NIST CSF 2.0 when there is no specific requirement, or the Essential Eight and ASD Essentials, ISO/IEC 27001:2022, the Information Security Manual (ISM) or a client’s own requirements when those apply. We agree it on the free scoping call.

How long does a gap assessment take?

It depends on your size and how much is in scope. We agree a timeline in your fixed quote. Your team’s time is mainly a few focused interviews and sharing existing documents, and we tell you upfront what we need.

What do we need to prepare?

Nothing special. We send a short list of what helps, such as existing policies, network or cloud diagrams, recent reports and screenshots of key settings. If something does not exist, that is a finding, not a problem.

How much does a security gap assessment cost?

It is a fixed quote based on your size, the framework and the scope, agreed after a free scoping call and before any work starts.

What happens after the assessment?

You can use the roadmap with your own IT team or managed service provider, or Cautio can help close the gaps through hands-on hardening, tailored policies, staff awareness training, Essential Eight uplift or an ongoing virtual CISO.

Get an Honest Baseline.

A free scoping call to agree the framework, the scope and a fixed price. No obligation, and no sales pitch for products we do not sell.